Monday, May 7, 2012

Dialectics: Freedom and Happiness


     In The Matrix, freedom and happiness have a conversation - rather, a tussle - over which is more important. The two are commonly thought of as are nearly synonymous, especially in america - freedom is the american dream! However, these two concepts are nearly mutually exclusive within the world of The Matrix. The choice of whether to dwell in the luxurious amenities of the dream-world of the Matrix or to suffer in the cold, dank, horrifying reality of the world is a choice that must be faced by all the people who are free, or have the opportunity to be free from the Matrix. 
Freedom makes its point though the stories of Neo, Morpheus, and Trinity. Through freedom, Neo is able to satisfy the itch that drives him mad while he lives within the Matrix. He is able to do amazing things now that his mind is free, and even more so when he realizes that he is The One. Because he was freed he met Trinity, which turns out at the end of the movie to be a great incentive for him.      Indeed, Neo gains much in terms of abilities and friendships via his freedom. As argued by the the crew of the Nebuchadnezzar and Neo specifically, the ability to realize the true world and the full potential of someone who is free outweigh the benefits of peaceful existence. 

      However, this freedom comes at a grave price. He is forced to live on a somewhat derelict ship, underground, living in constant fear of being slaughtered by sentinel robots. Worse, when he inevitably enters the Matrix, he must constantly evade the “Agents” of the Matrix mainframe under pain of death. Those who live outside the Matrix eat goop, for lack of a better term, in order to survive. Within the Matrix, people enjoy the wonders of a perfectly cooked steak, or delicious noodles, without the preconception that it is all fake. They can raise a family in peace, own a home, and live out the american dream. They live with the notion that they are free, and therefore, the side of happiness would argue that they are as free as they need to be. 

      These arguments have basis in many world affairs today. Even now, there are many arguments discussing the benefits and harms of democratic society. As some would say, “If pro is the opposite of con, what is the opposite of progress?” There is no argument that a dictatorial society would make decisions far more decisively than a democracy. Obviously, the framework of the Matrix does not perfectly parallel every application of its dialectic argument. However, by comparing the seemingly argumentative values of freedom versus happiness, which in some cases may be mutually exclusive, we can determine what each means to us as human beings. 

      Freedom might argue that happiness cannot exist without freedom. As suggested by Neo’s itching that something is wrong with the world, Neo is not truly happy in the Matrix. By extension, this could either mean that Neo is unique, or that everyone is not truly happy in the Matrix. However, happiness might counteract using a similar argument, saying that the Matrix is freedom because it offers happiness. Because people can live out their dreams in the Matrix, happiness would argue that you can only be free if you are first happy. 

      Whichever side you decide to agree with might influence either political, religious, or simple life decisions that could shape the future of your life. 

1 comment:

  1. This is quite a good comparison- or tussle!- that you've set up, Kevin. From an American perspective, it doesn't come naturally to see freedom and happiness exclusively, but as your examples from the movie show, they can be very separate. This distinction makes me wonder why we still value freedom so much. There are some kinds of freedom that don't make you happy; especially that which exposes you to a nasty reality that you didn't see when you weren't free. Maybe our idea of freedom isn't as well-rounded as it could be in the U.S.

    An example that comes to mind is the unpleasant freedom that former slaves aquired after the abolition of slavery in our country. My simple understanding of what happened is this: for many of the freed, work opportunities other than the manual labor jobs of their past were very scarce, both because they never were educated and because discrimination closed much of society to them. In their former conditions, they at least had certain work that gave them food to eat and a place to live. One take on this situation is to see the certain existence as a slave as happiness and the uncertain existence of being free as unhappiness, but I guess that you could flip those things around depending on how you think of it, as you said in the conclusion of your blog post. In this example, someone who derives happiness from having power to decide how they live, not from security of food and shelter, would say that the confined existence as a slave is unhappiness and the free existence is happiness.

    It seems that for some people, the power (or perceived power) to do what they like is what makes them happy- that's how they equate freedom with happiness. But freedom isn't always defined as having the power to do what you like; sometimes freedom is more along the lines of just having the power to not do what others would like you to do.

    ReplyDelete