Wednesday, October 19, 2011

iMedia - Thumbs on fire.

Until very recently, a ringing phone during dinner was considered a nuisance and a blatant intrusion into private family life. The fact of the matter is, today phones have become so commonplace and close at hand that they are almost like an appendage. Useful as they are, things always need to be kept in perspective and under control. With the near epidemic use of cellphones for calling, texting, Facebooking, playing games, and other things, I’m not sure that their usefulness outweighs their harm. 

The most striking part of the image above is the fact that the phone is not off to the side. This may seem irrelevant, but its position on the plate makes it seem like the phone is of special importance, and is to be respected as a family item rather than actively used as a utensil. More and more frequently kids, and grown-ups, too, are utterly distracted from their families at the dinner table. A brief glance around a restaurant will reveal that most families are looking out the window, away from each other, or at their portable electronic devices. Many people find this horrifying, the fact that a couple of dots on a screen can be more important than a real relationship. This is a generalizing and slightly condescending view on the power of technology, however, and is not an accurate description of the actions taken on a cell phone.

My mom attended a conference by psychologist Wendy Mogel the other night, and one of the topics discussed was how teens are so “addicted” to cell phones and sites like Facebook. Dr. Mogel claims that the way young people interact with each other is similar to how kids played outside in her generation. Both serve as a place for interaction away from parental control. When you’re outside, your parents cannot stop you from running around, or jumping, or yelling, or doing any fun thing. This is similar to the internet in that your parents can’t control what you say to your friends, and it is very difficult for them to limit where you go. It is OUR domain. So, instead of an isolated game of Pac-man lying on the plate, it is more like a portal away from parental control and into your own world. 

This sad truth defines our culture because America is recognized as one of the most distracted nations on the planet. Despite the many social, useful, and almost necessary applications of cell phones, they should not be considered more important than a family relationship. The value of independence is almost immeasurable to teens, and cell phones offer just that. However, there is a time and place for that, and it is certainly not in a class or at a dinner table. However, people have become so connected to cell phones that they are like an item of clothing. As stated in Orlando, clothes define who we are, and cell phones certainly fall into that category. For example, a boy with a pink phone would not be viewed quite the same way as a girl with a pink phone. Looking back on the evolution of the cell phone, the timeframe in which it has rooted itself so deeply in our culture is astonishingly brief. At this rate, we can only wonder what our phones will be like in 10 years. They may not just be on our plates, they may be an integrated part of the plate. In fact, they might literally be a part of us. 

1 comment:

  1. Mr. Benson,
    I agree with you that mobile electronic devices have become an integral part of modern day society, especially among the younger demographic. More and more it seems that people are not considering it rude to whip out a cell-phone during a conversation or even during class! I like you believe that dependence on portable devices is sad, and I feel that unless action is taken the trend of disconnectedness in our society will only get worse. Already we see people not meeting vis à vis but instead talking through text, and we see many young adults having problems concentrating for long periods of time

    As a mitigating factor towards the idea that people are not physically socializing, you mentioned that cell-phones and portable media are what the outdoors was for past generations in that young adults can interact without being under their parents' yoke. What you failed to mention is that although portable media is a substitute for seeing people, it is a cheap one. This is because valuable social experiences are lost when you only interact with virtual people; the ability to read and act properly towards in the flesh people is thus diminished. And, real people will always be important--you can't go on real dates, have real job interviews, or raise a real family online.

    On the note of problems that come from using electronics, I would like to expand upon the issue of the distractedness and short attention spans so prevalent in the younger generations which you, Kevin, briefly mentioned. I would like to point out that electronics in general rewire the brain, causing shorter attention spans, attention disorders, and which in general distract from important activities such as homework. It follows that portable electronics can only exacerbate these problems since they are with us all the time (and they sometimes create new ways of being distracted: texting while driving).

    Kevin, for a whole slew of reasons media--and especially portable media--is dangerous. Not only does it take away from social opportunities, it hurts attention spans and can end lives (texting while driving). I'm very glad you took up this issue and wrote about it. I only hope that you yourself aren't being distracted by Facebook or texting, and that you will complete the Blogging Around prompt ;).

    ReplyDelete